Later artistic depiction of Xu Jie in a historical painting or book illustration.
Later artistic depiction of Xu Jie in a historical painting or book illustration.

1503 CE–1583 CE

Senior Grand Secretary and statesman of the Ming

Xu Jie

徐阶

Xu Jie was Senior Grand Secretary during the Jiajing and Longqing reigns. Known for caution and steadiness, he played a leading role in the fall of Yan Song, supported the succession that led to the Wanli reign, and helped stabilize the new court.

1503 CE–1583 CEMing Dynasty

PROFILE

Xu Jie was Senior Grand Secretary during the Jiajing and Longqing reigns. Known for caution and steadiness, he played a leading role in the fall of Yan Song, supported the succession that led to the Wanli reign, and helped stabilize the new court.

Alternate names
Zisheng; Cunzhai
Courtesy name
Zisheng
Art name
Shaohu
Period
Ming
Dynasty/Regime
Ming Dynasty
Identity
Senior Grand Secretary and statesman of the Ming
Ethnicity/People
Not reliably established in the historical record
Native place
Huating County, Songjiang Prefecture (present-day Songjiang District, Shanghai)
Date of birth
October 9, 1503
Place of birth
Xuanping County, Zhejiang (now part of Wuyi County, Zhejiang)
Date of death
1583
Place of death
Unknown
Highest office
See Biography and Major Activities
Major achievements
Senior Grand Secretary during the Jiajing and Longqing reigns; known for caution and steadiness; helped remove Yan Song, supported the succession that led to the Wanli reign, and protected the new court

LIFE TIMELINE

BIOGRAPHY

Biography

Family Background and Early Years

In 1501, the fourteenth year of Hongzhi, Xu Jie's father Xu Fu became assistant magistrate of Xuanping County in Zhejiang. Xu Jie was born on the twentieth day of the ninth lunar month of 1503 at the county government office. His mother was Lady Gu, Xu Fu's third wife. Xu survived two near-fatal accidents in childhood. At about one year old, a servant accidentally dropped him into a well; after being rescued he remained unconscious for three days before recovering. In 1507, at age five, he fell from a cliff while traveling with his father through the Kuocang Mountains, but his clothes caught on a tree and saved him, astonishing contemporaries.

Xu was considered exceptionally intelligent from childhood. While he studied at an old monastery that was rumored to be haunted, nothing happened to him, and Xu Fu took this as further evidence that his son was unusual. Xu later studied under accomplished teachers, reading the Elementary Learning and the Four Books, and was able to memorize them quickly. In 1511 Xu Fu was transferred to serve as assistant magistrate of Ningdu in Jiangxi, and Xu Jie accompanied him. On one occasion Xu Fu proposed a matching couplet: “The father returns from afar and the son goes afar to welcome him—the affection between father and son is Heaven-given.” Xu immediately answered: “The ruler dwells above and the minister below—the duty between ruler and minister belongs to human relations.” Xu Fu thereafter began training him systematically in composition.

In 1513 Xu returned with his father to Huating and studied beside Shaohu Lake west of the city, taking Shaohu as his art name. In 1517, at age fifteen, he passed the licentiate examination and entered the Huating county school. Two years later he participated in the Yingtian provincial examination with excellent preliminary results but failed to obtain the degree.

In 1520, the fifteenth year of Zhengde, Nie Bao, a disciple of Wang Yangming, became magistrate of Huating. Among the students he recognized Xu Jie as “material for the state” and, outside official duties, instructed him in the learning of the sages, that is, the School of Mind associated with Wang Yangming. Xu thereafter applied himself with renewed determination and resolved to place in the first class of the palace examination. In 1522, the first year of Jiajing, he placed seventh in the Yingtian provincial examination and became a provincial graduate.

Entering Office and Early Setbacks

In the third month of 1523, the second year of Jiajing, Xu passed the metropolitan examination and ranked third in the first class of the palace examination, receiving the distinction of tanhua and the jinshi degree. When he paid respects to the grand secretaries, Senior Grand Secretary Yang Tinghe was impressed and predicted, “This young man's name and rank will not be below those of men like us.” Xu was then appointed compiler in the Hanlin Academy according to precedent and requested leave to return home and marry Lady Shen.

In the eighth month of 1524, Xu traveled north to take up office. Near Xuzhou he dreamed that his father called to him; while returning, he learned at Pengcheng that his father had died and went home to observe mourning. In 1527, after completing mourning, he returned to his Hanlin post. He later participated in revising works including the Collected Statutes of the Great Ming and the Established Ceremonial Rites. While at the Hanlin Academy, Xu was assigned to teach eunuchs in the Inner Study Hall. Unlike earlier officials who had treated the assignment perfunctorily, Xu arrived each day at the hour of the tiger and did not leave until the hour of the monkey. He strictly supervised the eunuch students, teaching not only literacy but warning them not to violate ancestral regulations by interfering in politics. His conduct was well regarded. When he was later demoted, more than ten eunuchs were said to have clung to the hall pillars and wept.

In 1530, Senior Grand Secretary Zhang Cong proposed replacing statues of Confucius in the temples with wooden spirit tablets and changing Confucius's title from “Great Accomplished, Most Sage, King Who Propagates Culture” to titles appropriate to ancient worthies and scholars. On the twenty-ninth day of the tenth month Xu submitted a memorial presenting three reasons the title need not be removed and five reasons it must not be removed. At a court session on the first day of the eleventh month, Zhang Cong rebuked Xu face to face. Xu argued back sternly and forcefully. Zhang angrily said, “You have betrayed me.” Xu replied, “Betrayal arises only from prior attachment. I have never attached myself to Your Excellency; how then can you speak of betrayal?” Emperor Shizong supported Zhang Cong and demoted Xu to judicial official in Yanping Prefecture, Fujian. According to one story, the emperor even wrote the words “Xu Jie is a petty man; never employ him again” on a column at the Nanjing Imperial University.

This episode became an important turning point in Xu's career. In later years he repeatedly recalled it as a lesson against impetuosity and rashness and as a reason to cultivate a more cautious political style.

Local Office and Return to Favor

Xu arrived in Yanping in the fourth month of 1531 and by the seventh month was acting as prefect. He carefully adjudicated lawsuits, sought to educate the people through ritual and moral principle, destroyed illicit shrines, founded community schools, and personally wrote maxims from Song Confucian scholars for elementary instruction. He also reformed procedures for remitting silver taxes in order to reduce abuse by clerks. In the twelfth month, he personally led local militia against bandits in Youxi and captured 120 people within half a month. During his Yanping tenure he formed close friendships with Zheng Qingyun and Huang Zhuo through shared hardship.

In the third month of 1534, Xu was transferred to serve as assistant prefect of Huangzhou in Huguang. Elders in Yanping erected a stone inscription praising his achievements, and students escorted him as far as Jianning. When he reached Yanling he was reassigned as assistant surveillance commissioner of Zhejiang in charge of educational administration. In the tenth month of 1536 he was transferred to Jiangxi as vice surveillance commissioner, still supervising education. During his time in Jiangxi, relatives of Grand Secretary Xia Yan sought advancement through Xu; Xu refused them directly, angering Xia.

In the second month of 1539 Zhang Cong died. In the fifth month Emperor Shizong was selecting attendants for Crown Prince Zhu Zairui as the latter began formal residence outside the inner palace. Minister of Personnel Xu Zan ensured that Xu Jie was selected, and Xu was recalled to the capital as Director of Studies in the Directorate of the Heir Apparent and concurrently Hanlin reader. In the sixth month of 1540 his mother, Lady Gu, died, and he again returned home for mourning. In the twelfth month of 1542 he was promoted to Chancellor of the Imperial University.

Central Office and Entry into the Grand Secretariat

In the eleventh month of 1543 Xu was promoted to Right Vice Minister of Rites. In an intercalary first month of 1545 he was transferred to Right Vice Minister of Personnel. On taking up the post he wrote a warning to himself in the main hall of the Ministry of Personnel: “Take heed, Xu Jie! You gained the jinshi degree at twenty-one and at forty-three assist the celestial officials. The state's favor is profound—how will you repay it? If you do not exhaust your loyalty and labor, but instead form factions to exclude the worthy, accept bribes and sell the law, betray public duty to seek favor, or cling to office for private gain, may the spirits strike you down and extend the punishment to your descendants. Ah—this is to be feared!” In the twelfth month he was promoted to Left Vice Minister of Personnel. His diligence won him a reputation for competence, and Minister of Personnel Xiong Xia especially valued him.

In 1552, the thirty-first year of Jiajing, Xu entered the Grand Secretariat. He gained Emperor Shizong's favor through skill in composing qingci, the Daoist-style petitions used at court, and by exposing the crimes of Qiu Luan. Thereafter he outwardly served Senior Grand Secretary Yan Song with great caution while secretly helping remonstrating officials persecuted by Yan. After ten years of restraint, Yan Song fell from power in 1561, and Xu succeeded him as Senior Grand Secretary.

As Senior Grand Secretary

After becoming Senior Grand Secretary, Xu declared that he would “return awe and favor to the sovereign, return administrative affairs to the offices, and return appointments, punishments, and rewards to public judgment.” When Emperor Shizong died in 1566, Xu drafted the “Jiajing Testamentary Edict,” reversing many of Yan Song's policies, redressing wrongful cases, and ending costly Daoist rites and other abuses. Officials at court and throughout the country reportedly raised their hands in celebration, comparing the document with the “Edict on the Jiajing Accession” drafted by Yang Tinghe and calling the two “the foremost policies for correcting the beginning and correcting the end.”

During the Longqing reign, Xu continued as Senior Grand Secretary. He repeatedly mediated conflicts between Emperor Muzong and the outer court and prevented eunuchs from gaining greater authority. In 1568, the second year of Longqing, Xu retired and returned home.

Later Years

After Xu's retirement, younger members of his household abused the family's influence and committed numerous offenses. Xu was implicated and on several occasions came close to imprisonment, forcing him to write to friends for assistance. Gao Gong and others also reopened old cases to attack him. Xu died at his home in Huating in 1583, the eleventh year of Wanli, at the age of eighty-one. He was posthumously granted the title Grand Preceptor and given the posthumous name Wenzhen.

Major Activities

Political Activity

The most prominent episode in Xu Jie's political career was the removal of Yan Song. While Yan dominated government, Xu served him cautiously in public, accumulated strength in private, and covertly aided remonstrating officials persecuted by Yan. When Yan fell in 1561, Xu became Senior Grand Secretary. During his tenure he reversed many of Yan's policies, redressed wrongful cases, and ended costly Daoist rituals.

Late in the Jiajing reign, Xu successfully persuaded Emperor Shizong not to make a southern journey to Chengtian Prefecture, thereby halting large-scale construction there. During the emperor's final illness, Xu urged him to stop taking elixirs and ordered the execution of court alchemists and eunuchs who had colluded with them.

While serving in the Ministry of Personnel, Xu reformed longstanding abuses and improved administrative efficiency. When teaching eunuchs in the Inner Study Hall, he instructed them in moral principles and attempted to reshape their role and conduct at court.

Literature and Scholarship

Xu Jie was a second-generation disciple in the intellectual line of Wang Shouren. He studied under Nie Bao in his youth and received instruction in Wang Yangming's School of Mind. While in the Hanlin Academy he associated with Luo Hongxian and other followers of Wang's learning. Xu was skilled in composing qingci, which helped win Emperor Shizong's favor. His writings were collected in the Shijingtang Collection; the “Preface Presented to Assistant Commissioner Zhou Meiya on His Departure for Henan” contains his own account of his early life.

Travels and Places of Activity

Xu traveled widely in north and south China. He was born in Xuanping, Zhejiang, accompanied his father to Ningdu in Jiangxi as a child, and later returned to Huating. His offices took him to Yanping in Fujian, Huangzhou in Huguang, Zhejiang, Jiangxi, and other regions, and in old age he returned to Huating.

Relations with Contemporaries

Xu Jie had a teacher-student relationship with Nie Bao and was a friend of Luo Hongxian. In Yanping he became a close companion of Zheng Qingyun and Huang Zhuo through shared difficulties. At the central court he was friendly with remonstrating officials such as Yang Jisheng and secretly tried to protect them. He trained later statesmen including Zhang Juzheng and had a complex relationship with Gao Gong.

Personal Relations

Family

Xu Fu: father

Lady Gu: birth mother

Shen Zhongheng: wife

Lady Zhang: later wife

Xu Fan: son

Teachers and Friends

Nie Bao: teacher

Luo Hongxian: friend

Zheng Qingyun: friend

Huang Zhuo: friend

Yang Jisheng: friend

Rulers

Zhu Houcong, Emperor Shizong of Ming: ruler and minister

Zhu Zaiji, Emperor Muzong of Ming: ruler and minister

Zhu Yijun, Emperor Shenzong of Ming: ruler and minister

Colleagues

Yan Song: colleague and opponent

Zhang Cong: colleague and conflict

Xia Yan: colleague and conflict

Gao Gong: colleague and conflict

Zhang Juzheng: student and colleague

Conflicts

Yan Song

Zhang Cong

Gao Gong

Historical Assessment

Ming and Contemporary Assessments

Zhi Dalun criticized Xu Jie for “entering the inner court by relying on mysterious qingci compositions, flattering others while in office, and accomplishing no political achievements,” although he also acknowledged improvement during the Longqing period. Feng Menglong admired Xu's resourcefulness, strategic intelligence, breadth, and judgment. Contemporaries praised him as a “senior statesman” and “famous chancellor.”

Early and Mid-Qing

Zhang Tingyu and the compilers of the History of Ming described Xu as “quick-witted and intelligent, possessed of strategic judgment, yet inwardly grave and not revealing himself.” They praised his restraint in “serving Yan Song cautiously” and his later action when “after Yan Song fell, Xu Jie replaced him as Senior Grand Secretary and reversed all of Yan's policies.”

Late Qing and Republican Period

Modern-era historians offered more varied assessments. They generally recognized Xu's achievement in bringing down Yan Song and correcting abuses, while also criticizing practices such as favoring private associates and indulging the misconduct of his descendants.

Modern Period

Tan Ping has argued that, compared with his student Zhang Juzheng, Xu Jie was steadier and less attached to political power. Modern scholarship remains divided, but some scholars view him positively, emphasizing his cultivation of statesmen such as Zhang Juzheng and his considerable influence on the later development of the Grand Secretariat.

LOCAL NETWORK

FIGURES ASSOCIATED WITH THIS DYNASTY

Bibliography

  • History of Ming*, “Biography of Xu Jie”